Skip to content

Enzymes

By the end of this section, you will be able to:

  • Describe the role of enzymes in metabolic pathways
  • Explain how enzymes function as molecular catalysts
  • Discuss enzyme regulation by various factors

A substance that helps a chemical reaction to occur is a catalyst, and the special molecules that catalyze biochemical reactions are enzymes. Almost all enzymes are proteins, comprised of amino acid chains, and they perform the critical task of lowering the activation energies of chemical reactions inside the cell. Enzymes do this by binding to the reactant molecules, and holding them in such a way as to make the chemical bond-breaking and bond-forming processes take place more readily. It is important to remember that enzymes do not change the reaction’s ΔG. In other words, they do not change whether a reaction is exergonic (spontaneous) or endergonic. This is because they do not change the reactants’ or products’ free energy. They only reduce the activation energy required to reach the transition state (below).

A graph of energy against reaction path, comparing a reaction with and without a catalyst. Both curves start at the same reactants level, rise over an activation-energy hump, and settle at the same, lower products level; the catalyzed curve's hump is smaller.
Enzymes lower the reaction’s activation energy but do not change the reaction’s free energy.
Extended description

A line graph titled Activation Energy, with Energy on the vertical axis and Reaction path on the horizontal axis. Two curves start together at a flat ‘reactants’ level on the left, each rise to a peak, then drop to a flat ‘products’ level on the right, lower than the start. The solid purple curve (Reaction without catalyst) rises to a taller peak; the dashed red curve (Reaction with catalyst) rises to a shorter peak partway up the purple one. A double-headed arrow from the reactants level to each peak marks that curve’s activation energy, and a double-headed arrow labeled ΔG marks the drop from the reactants level to the shared products level, the same for both curves.

Enzyme Active Site and Substrate Specificity

The chemical reactants to which an enzyme binds are the enzyme’s substrates. There may be one or more substrates, depending on the particular chemical reaction. In some reactions, a single-reactant substrate breaks down into multiple products. In others, two substrates may come together to create one larger molecule. Two reactants might also enter a reaction, both become modified, and leave the reaction as two products. The location within the enzyme where the substrate binds is the enzyme’s active site. This is where the “action” happens. Since enzymes are proteins, there is a unique combination of amino acid residues (also side chains, or R groups) within the active site. Different properties characterize each residue. These can be large or small, weakly acidic or basic, hydrophilic or hydrophobic, positively or negatively charged, or neutral. The unique combination of amino acid residues, their positions, sequences, structures, and properties, creates a very specific chemical environment within the active site. This specific environment is suited to bind, albeit briefly, to a specific chemical substrate (or substrates). Due to this jigsaw puzzle-like match between an enzyme and its substrates (which adapts to find the best fit between the transition state and the active site), enzymes are known for their specificity. The “best fit” results from the shape and the amino acid functional group’s attraction to the substrate. There is a specifically matched enzyme for each substrate and, thus, for each chemical reaction; however, there is flexibility as well.

The fact that active sites are so perfectly suited to provide specific environmental conditions also means that they are subject to local environmental influences. It is true that increasing the environmental temperature generally increases reaction rates, enzyme-catalyzed or otherwise. However, increasing or decreasing the temperature outside of an optimal range can affect chemical bonds within the active site in such a way that they are less well suited to bind substrates. High temperatures will eventually cause enzymes, like other biological molecules, to denature, a process that changes the substance’s natural properties. Likewise, the local environment’s pH can also affect enzyme function. Active site amino acid residues have their own acidic or basic properties that are optimal for catalysis. These residues are sensitive to changes in pH that can impair the way substrate molecules bind. Enzymes are suited to function best within a certain pH range, and, as with temperature, extreme environmental pH values (acidic or basic) can cause enzymes to denature.

Induced Fit and Enzyme Function

For many years, scientists thought that enzyme-substrate binding took place in a simple “lock-and-key” fashion. This model asserted that the enzyme and substrate fit together perfectly in one instantaneous step. However, current research supports a more refined view scientists call induced fit (below). This model expands upon the lock-and-key model by describing a more dynamic interaction between enzyme and substrate. As the enzyme and substrate come together, their interaction causes a mild shift in the enzyme’s structure that confirms an ideal binding arrangement between the enzyme and the substrate’s transition state. This ideal binding maximizes the enzyme’s ability to catalyze its reaction.

Link to Learning. View an induced fit animation at this website.

When an enzyme binds its substrate, it forms an enzyme-substrate complex. This complex lowers the reaction’s activation energy and promotes its rapid progression in one of many ways. On a basic level, enzymes promote chemical reactions that involve more than one substrate by bringing the substrates together in an optimal orientation. The appropriate region (atoms and bonds) of one molecule is juxtaposed to the other molecule’s appropriate region with which it must react. Another way in which enzymes promote substrate reaction is by creating an optimal environment within the active site for the reaction to occur. Certain chemical reactions might proceed best in a slightly acidic or non-polar environment. The chemical properties that emerge from the particular arrangement of amino acid residues within an active site create the perfect environment for an enzyme’s specific substrates to react.

You have learned that the activation energy required for many reactions includes the energy involved in manipulating or slightly contorting chemical bonds so that they can easily break and allow others to reform. Enzymatic action can aid this process. The enzyme-substrate complex can lower the activation energy by contorting substrate molecules in such a way as to facilitate bond-breaking, helping to reach the transition state. Finally, enzymes can also lower activation energies by taking part in the chemical reaction itself. The amino acid residues can provide certain ions or chemical groups that actually form covalent bonds with substrate molecules as a necessary step of the reaction process. In these cases, it is important to remember that the enzyme will always return to its original state at the reaction’s completion. One of enzymes’ hallmark properties is that they remain ultimately unchanged by the reactions they catalyze. After an enzyme catalyzes a reaction, it releases its product(s).

A four-step sequence showing a substrate entering an enzyme's active site, the enzyme changing shape slightly as the substrate binds, and the resulting products leaving the active site.
According to the induced-fit model, both enzyme and substrate undergo dynamic conformational changes upon binding. The enzyme contorts the substrate into its transition state, thereby increasing the reaction’s rate.
Extended description

Four panels read left to right, each showing the same crescent-shaped enzyme with a notch (the active site). Panel 1, ‘Substrate entering active site of enzyme’: a green two-lobed substrate approaches the notch from above, arrow pointing down. Panel 2, ‘Enzyme/substrate complex’: the substrate now sits in the notch, and the enzyme’s edges have closed slightly around it, labeled ‘Enzyme changes shape slightly as substrate binds.’ Panel 3, ‘Enzyme/products complex’: the substrate has been converted into two differently shaped pieces, a blue rounded piece and a yellow triangular piece, still seated in the notch. Panel 4, ‘Products leaving active site of enzyme’: the blue and yellow product pieces move up and away from the now-empty notch, arrows pointing up and outward.

Metabolism Control Through Enzyme Regulation

It would seem ideal to have a scenario in which all the encoded enzymes in an organism’s genome existed in abundant supply and functioned optimally under all cellular conditions, in all cells, at all times. In reality, this is far from the case. A variety of mechanisms ensure that this does not happen. Cellular needs and conditions vary from cell to cell, and change within individual cells over time. The required enzymes and energetic demands of stomach cells are different from those of fat storage cells, skin cells, blood cells, and nerve cells. Furthermore, a digestive cell works much harder to process and break down nutrients during the time that closely follows a meal compared with many hours after a meal. As these cellular demands and conditions vary, so do the amounts and functionality of different enzymes.

Since the rates of biochemical reactions are controlled by activation energy, and enzymes lower and determine activation energies for chemical reactions, the relative amounts and functioning of the variety of enzymes within a cell ultimately determine which reactions will proceed and at which rates. This determination is tightly controlled. In certain cellular environments, environmental factors like pH and temperature partly control enzyme activity. There are other mechanisms through which cells control enzyme activity and determine the rates at which various biochemical reactions will occur.

Molecular Regulation of Enzymes

Enzymes can be regulated in ways that either promote or reduce their activity. There are many different kinds of molecules that inhibit or promote enzyme function, and various mechanisms exist for doing so. For example, in some cases of enzyme inhibition, an inhibitor molecule is similar enough to a substrate that it can bind to the active site and simply block the substrate from binding. When this happens, the enzyme is inhibited through competitive inhibition, because an inhibitor molecule competes with the substrate for active site binding (below). On the other hand, in noncompetitive inhibition, an inhibitor molecule binds to the enzyme in a location other than the active site, called an allosteric site, but still manages to prevent substrate binding to the active site. Some inhibitor molecules bind to enzymes in a location where their binding induces a conformational change that reduces the enzyme activity as it no longer effectively catalyzes the conversion of the substrate to product.

A graph of rate of reaction against substrate concentration, comparing a normal enzyme with an enzyme in the presence of a competitive inhibitor and with an enzyme in the presence of a noncompetitive inhibitor.
Competitive and noncompetitive inhibition affect the reaction’s rate differently. Competitive inhibitors affect the initial rate but do not affect the maximal rate; whereas, noncompetitive inhibitors affect the maximal rate.
Extended description

A line graph titled Enzyme Inhibition, with Rate of reaction on the vertical axis and Substrate concentration on the horizontal axis. All three curves start at the origin and rise, then level off. The purple ‘Normal enzyme’ curve rises fastest and levels off highest. The green ‘Competitive inhibitor’ curve rises more slowly at first but converges with the normal-enzyme curve’s plateau at high substrate concentration. The blue ‘Noncompetitive inhibitor’ curve rises slowest and levels off at a distinctly lower plateau than the other two, even at high substrate concentration.

Some inhibitor molecules bind to enzymes in a location where their binding induces a conformational change that reduces the enzyme’s affinity for its substrate. This type of inhibition is an allosteric inhibition (below). More than one polypeptide comprise most allosterically regulated enzymes, meaning that they have more than one protein subunit. When an allosteric inhibitor binds to an enzyme, all active sites on the protein subunits change slightly such that they bind their substrates with less efficiency. There are allosteric activators as well as inhibitors. Allosteric activators bind to locations on an enzyme away from the active site, inducing a conformational change that increases the affinity of the enzyme’s active site(s) for its substrate(s).

Two side-by-side diagrams of a four-subunit allosteric enzyme: one shows an inhibitor binding away from the active site and locking the enzyme in its inactive form, and the other shows an activator binding away from the active site and stabilizing the enzyme's active form.
Allosteric inhibitors modify the enzyme’s active site so that substrate binding is reduced or prevented. In contrast, allosteric activators modify the enzyme’s active site so that the affinity for the substrate increases. Credit: Rao, A., Hawkins, A., Fletcher, S. and Tag, A. Department of Biology, Texas A&M University.
Extended description

Diagram titled Allosteric Activators and Inhibitors, showing a four-lobed, pinwheel-shaped enzyme with an active site (one of four) and a regulatory site (one of four) labeled on one copy. Top row: the enzyme’s ‘Inactive Form,’ with a non-functional active site, sits at left; a red, crescent-shaped inhibitor approaches from above and, once bound at the regulatory site, produces the ‘Stabilized Inactive Form’ at right. Bottom row: the enzyme’s ‘Active Form’ sits at left; a green, triangular activator approaches from above and, once bound at the regulatory site, produces the ‘Stabilized Active Form’ at right, with a green triangle now also fitted into the active site. A double-headed vertical arrow labeled ‘Oscillation’ connects the inactive and active forms in the left column, showing the enzyme naturally toggles between the two shapes until a regulator locks it in one.

Everyday Connection. Drug Discovery by Looking for Inhibitors of Key Enzymes in Specific Pathways

A close-up photograph of several red, capsule-shaped pills scattered on a white surface, each embossed with the text '8 HOUR'.
Have you ever wondered how pharmaceutical drugs are developed? (credit: Deborah Austin)

Enzymes are key components of metabolic pathways. Understanding how enzymes work and how they can be regulated is a key principle behind developing many pharmaceutical drugs (above) on the market today. Biologists working in this field collaborate with other scientists, usually chemists, to design drugs.

Consider statins for example—which is a class of drugs that reduces cholesterol levels. These compounds are essentially inhibitors of the enzyme HMG-CoA reductase. HMG-CoA reductase is the enzyme that synthesizes cholesterol from lipids in the body. By inhibiting this enzyme, the drug reduces cholesterol levels synthesized in the body. Similarly, acetaminophen, popularly marketed under the brand name Tylenol, is an inhibitor of the enzyme cyclooxygenase. While it is effective in providing relief from fever and inflammation (pain), scientists still do not completely understand its mechanism of action.

How are drugs developed? One of the first challenges in drug development is identifying the specific molecule that the drug is intended to target. In the case of statins, HMG-CoA reductase is the drug target. Researchers identify targets through painstaking research in the laboratory. Identifying the target alone is not sufficient. Scientists also need to know how the target acts inside the cell and which reactions go awry in the case of disease. Once researchers identify the target and the pathway, then the actual drug design process begins. During this stage, chemists and biologists work together to design and synthesize molecules that can either block or activate a particular reaction. However, this is only the beginning: both if and when a drug prototype is successful in performing its function, then it must undergo many tests from in vitro experiments to clinical trials before it can obtain FDA approval to be on the market.

Many enzymes don’t work optimally, or even at all, unless bound to other specific non-protein helper molecules, either temporarily through ionic or hydrogen bonds or permanently through stronger covalent bonds. Two types of helper molecules are cofactors and coenzymes. Binding to these molecules promotes optimal conformation and function for their respective enzymes. Cofactors are inorganic ions such as iron (Fe²⁺) and magnesium (Mg²⁺). One example of an enzyme that requires a metal ion as a cofactor is the enzyme that builds DNA molecules, DNA polymerase, which requires a bound zinc ion (Zn²⁺) to function. Coenzymes are organic helper molecules, with a basic atomic structure comprised of carbon and hydrogen, which are required for enzyme action. The most common sources of coenzymes are dietary vitamins (below). Some vitamins are precursors to coenzymes and others act directly as coenzymes. Vitamin C is a coenzyme for multiple enzymes that take part in building the important connective tissue component, collagen. An important step in breaking down glucose to yield energy is catalysis by a multi-enzyme complex scientists call pyruvate dehydrogenase. Pyruvate dehydrogenase is a complex of several enzymes that actually requires one cofactor (a magnesium ion) and five different organic coenzymes to catalyze its specific chemical reaction. Therefore, enzyme function is, in part, regulated by an abundance of various cofactors and coenzymes, which the diets of most organisms supply.

A labeled grid of the molecular structures of eight dietary vitamins and their coenzyme forms: Vitamin A (retinol), folic acid (folate), Vitamin B1 (thiamin), Vitamin C (ascorbic acid), Vitamin B2 (riboflavin), Vitamin D2 (calciferol), Vitamin B6 (pyridoxine), and Vitamin E (α-tocopherol).
Vitamins are important coenzymes or precursors of coenzymes, and are required for enzymes to function properly. Multivitamin capsules usually contain mixtures of all the vitamins at different percentages.

Enzyme Compartmentalization

In eukaryotic cells, molecules such as enzymes are usually compartmentalized into different organelles. This allows for yet another level of regulation of enzyme activity. Enzymes required only for certain cellular processes are sometimes housed separately along with their substrates, allowing for more efficient chemical reactions. Examples of this sort of enzyme regulation based on location and proximity include the enzymes involved in the latter stages of cellular respiration, which take place exclusively in the mitochondria, and the enzymes involved in digesting cellular debris and foreign materials, located within lysosomes.

Feedback Inhibition in Metabolic Pathways

Molecules can regulate enzyme function in many ways. However, a major question remains: What are these molecules and from where do they come? Some are cofactors and coenzymes, ions, and organic molecules, as you have learned. What other molecules in the cell provide enzymatic regulation, such as allosteric modulation, and competitive and noncompetitive inhibition? The answer is that a wide variety of molecules can perform these roles. Some include pharmaceutical and non-pharmaceutical drugs, toxins, and poisons from the environment. Perhaps the most relevant sources of enzyme regulatory molecules, with respect to cellular metabolism, are cellular metabolic reaction products themselves. In a most efficient and elegant way, cells have evolved to use their own reactions’ products for feedback inhibition of enzyme activity. Feedback inhibition involves using a reaction product to regulate its own further production (below). The cell responds to the abundance of specific products by slowing down production during anabolic or catabolic reactions. Such reaction products may inhibit the enzymes that catalyzed their production through the mechanisms that we described above.

A metabolic pathway flow chart in which threonine deaminase converts threonine through four intermediates and five enzymes into the end product isoleucine, which then feeds back to bind the enzyme's allosteric site and block the pathway.
Metabolic pathways are a series of reactions that multiple enzymes catalyze. Feedback inhibition, where the pathway’s end product inhibits an upstream step, is an important regulatory mechanism in cells. Metabolic pathways are a series of reactions catalyzed by multiple enzymes (Intermediates A – D, Enzymes 1 – 5). Feedback inhibition occurs when the pathway’s end product (here isoleucine) inhibits an upstream enzyme (indicated by red bar). In this example, isoleucine will bind to Threonine Deaminase (at the allosteric site) and prevent threonine from binding to this enzyme’s active site, effectively blocking this metabolic pathway. When isoleucine levels decrease, Threonine will then bind to Threonine Deaminase’s active site and the metabolic pathway will resume. This is an important regulatory mechanism in cells to inhibit the overproduction of a product. Credit: Rao, A., Ryan, K., Tag, A., Hawkins, A. and Fletcher S. Department of Biology, Texas A&M University.
Extended description

A flow chart with two loops sharing the threonine deaminase enzyme. Top loop, drawn with green arrows: ‘Initial Substrate (Threonine)’ feeds into ‘Threonine is in Active Site’ of ‘Enzyme 1 (Threonine Deaminase),’ which converts it stepwise through Intermediate A, Enzyme 2, Intermediate B, Enzyme 3, Intermediate C, Enzyme 4, Intermediate D, Enzyme 5, down to the ‘End Product (Isoleucine).’ Bottom loop, drawn with a red inhibition bar: the end product isoleucine loops back and binds threonine deaminase’s allosteric site, labeled ‘Isoleucine Binds to Allosteric Site,’ which blocks the active site (‘Feedback Inhibition — Active Site No Longer Available; Pathway Halted’) so threonine cannot bind. A separate arrow labeled ‘Isoleucine Dissociates’ shows the enzyme returning to its open state, with ‘Active Site Available,’ once isoleucine leaves, ready for threonine to bind again.

Producing both amino acids and nucleotides is controlled through feedback inhibition. Additionally, ATP is an allosteric regulator of some of the enzymes involved in sugar’s catabolic breakdown, the process that produces ATP. In this way, when ATP is abundant, the cell can prevent its further production. Remember that ATP is an unstable molecule that can spontaneously dissociate into ADP and inorganic phosphate. If too much ATP were present in a cell, much of it would go to waste. Alternatively, ADP serves as a positive allosteric regulator (an allosteric activator) for some of the same enzymes that ATP inhibits. Thus, when relative ADP levels are high compared to ATP, the cell is triggered to produce more ATP through sugar catabolism.

Summary

Enzymes are chemical catalysts that accelerate chemical reactions at physiological temperatures by lowering their activation energy. Enzymes are usually proteins consisting of one or more polypeptide chains. Enzymes have an active site that provides a unique chemical environment, comprised of certain amino acid R groups (residues). This unique environment is perfectly suited to convert particular chemical reactants for that enzyme, scientists call substrates, into unstable intermediates that they call transition states. Enzymes and substrates bind with an induced fit, which means that enzymes undergo slight conformational adjustments upon substrate contact, leading to full, optimal binding. Enzymes bind to substrates and catalyze reactions in four different ways: bringing substrates together in an optimal orientation, compromising the bond structures of substrates so that bonds can break down more easily, providing optimal environmental conditions for a reaction to occur, or participating directly in their chemical reaction by forming transient covalent bonds with the substrates.

Enzyme action must be regulated so that in a given cell at a given time, the desired reactions catalyze and the undesired reactions are not. Enzymes are regulated by cellular conditions, such as temperature and pH. They are also regulated through their location within a cell, sometimes compartmentalized so that they can only catalyze reactions under certain circumstances. Enzyme inhibition and activation via other molecules are other important ways that enzymes are regulated. Inhibitors can act competitively, noncompetitively, or allosterically. Noncompetitive inhibitors are usually allosteric. Activators can also enhance enzyme function allosterically. The most common method by which cells regulate the enzymes in metabolic pathways is through feedback inhibition. During feedback inhibition, metabolic pathway products serve as inhibitors (usually allosteric) of one or more of the enzymes (usually the first committed enzyme of the pathway) involved in the pathway that produces them.

Key terms

  • active site — enzyme’s specific region to which the substrate binds
  • allosteric inhibition — inhibition by a binding event at a site different from the active site, which induces a conformational change and reduces the enzyme’s affinity for its substrate
  • coenzyme — small organic molecule, such as a vitamin or its derivative, which is required to enhance an enzyme’s activity
  • cofactor — inorganic ion, such as iron and magnesium ions, required for optimal enzyme activity regulation
  • competitive inhibition — type of inhibition in which the inhibitor competes with the substrate molecule by binding to the enzyme’s active site
  • denature — process that changes a substance’s natural properties
  • feedback inhibition — a product’s effect of a reaction sequence to decrease its further production by inhibiting the first enzyme’s activity in the pathway that produces it
  • induced fit — dynamic fit between the enzyme and its substrate, in which both components modify their structures to allow for ideal binding
  • substrate — molecule on which the enzyme acts

Practice

Describe the role of enzymes in metabolic pathways

Which of the following is not true about enzymes?

An abundance of a metabolic pathway’s own end product can slow the pathway’s first enzyme through ________, in which the product itself binds and blocks further production.

Explain in your own words how enzyme feedback inhibition benefits a cell.

Show model answer
Feedback inhibition allows cells to control the amounts of metabolic products produced. If there is too much of a particular product relative to the cell’s needs, feedback inhibition effectively causes the cell to decrease production of that particular product. In general, this reduces the production of superfluous products and conserves energy, maximizing energy efficiency.

Did your answer mention:

Explain how enzymes function as molecular catalysts

Which of the following analogies best describes the induced-fit model of enzyme-substrate binding?

The region of an enzyme where its substrate binds is called the ________.

A chemical reactant to which an enzyme binds, and upon which it acts, is called the enzyme’s ________.

Discuss enzyme regulation by various factors

An allosteric inhibitor does which of the following?

An inhibitor molecule that binds directly to an enzyme’s active site, blocking the substrate from binding there, causes ________.

A process that changes a substance’s natural properties, such as an enzyme losing its shape from heat, extreme pH, or chemical exposure, is called ________.

With regard to enzymes, why are vitamins necessary for good health? Give examples.

Show model answer
Most vitamins and minerals act as coenzymes and cofactors for enzyme action. Many enzymes require the binding of certain cofactors or coenzymes to be able to catalyze their reactions. Since enzymes catalyze many important reactions, it is critical to obtain sufficient vitamins and minerals from the diet and from supplements. Vitamin C (ascorbic acid) is a coenzyme necessary for the action of enzymes that build collagen, an important protein component of connective tissue throughout the body. Magnesium ion (Mg²⁺) is an important cofactor that is necessary for the enzyme pyruvate dehydrogenase to catalyze part of the pathway that breaks down sugar to produce energy. Vitamins cannot be produced in the human body and therefore must be obtained in the diet.

Did your answer mention:

A small organic molecule, such as a vitamin or its derivative, required to enhance an enzyme’s activity is called a(n) ________.


This section is adapted from Biology 2e, Section 6.5: Enzymes by Mary Ann Clark, Jung Choi, Matthew Douglas, and OpenStax, © OpenStax, licensed under CC BY-NC-SA 4.0. Access the original for free at openstax.org. Changes: figures re-encoded as WebP, with five of the seven re-kinded from the manifest’s file-extension guess of “photo” to “diagram” after inspection (every one is a graph or illustration, not a photograph — only the red-capsule image is a true photo) and an extended description added for the five figures whose full reading (axis behavior, drawn panels, or flow-chart structure) is not carried by their captions (the activation-energy graph, the four-panel induced-fit sequence, the enzyme-inhibition graph, the allosteric activators/inhibitors diagram, and the feedback-inhibition pathway); ion charges in prose changed from the source’s “Fe++”/“Mg++”/“Zn++” to the site’s standard trailing-superscript notation (“Fe²⁺”, “Mg²⁺”, “Zn²⁺”); inline references to figures changed from the source’s parenthetical figure links to descriptive phrases (“below,” “above”) since figures are not numbered here; the Everyday Connection note kept its own figure (the pharmaceutical capsules) nested inside the callout, in its source position; the end-of-section Review Questions and Critical Thinking Questions adapted into the closing interactive Practice block (multiple choice and self-check respectively); and six key-term recall items (feedback inhibition, active site, substrate, competitive inhibition, denature, and coenzyme) added from the glossary to round out every objective group with an auto-graded item; and rubric checkpoints added to each self-check, decomposing its model answer (the source solution) into check-off clauses with no new claims.